"Wow, what a Hall of Fame class that will be."
"One of the best Hall of Fame classes ever? Most likely."
"Gwynn, Ripken, and McGwire? What a Hall of Fame class."
It seems like that was about 40 years ago when talking heads were muttering those statements. Sure enough, when Tony Gwynn, Cal Ripken, Jr., and Mark McGwire all announced their respective retirements in 2001, everyone knew that each would go storming through the doors of Cooperstown.
But when it came time to vote, one guy was not on many of the voters' ballots. He was, at one point, the undisputed single season home run king, Mark McGwire.
We all know what happened since 2001. Steroid speculation grew to a fever pitch, and many prominent sluggers, including McGwire and Sosa, were called to speak before Congress in 2005. Between Sosa's ability to forget how to speak English, and McGwire's constant claim of not wanting to talk about the past, the top sluggers in the game took a reputation hit.
The guy who fell the hardest was, of course, McGwire. He went from being a reluctant hero in 1998, to the poster boy of steroids-gone-wrong in 2005. McGwire was obviously out of the game at this point, but Sosa was still playing and had a chance to redeem himself in Baltimore.
But he didn't. He had a terrible year offensively, and when no one besides the Nationals wanted him for the 2006 season, he effectively retired.
Meanwhile, Bonds shot past both Sosa and McGwire to become the game's greatest slugger, breaking McGwire's home run record by slugging 73 home runs in 2001. He then began his climb to Hammerin' Hank's record by becoming the first player in some time to hit 600 and then 700 home runs in a career.
After Sosa's year hiatus, he was invited to attend the Rangers' spring training. He played his way onto the team and then began a march to 600 home runs. A few weeks ago, he hit his 600th home run against his old team, the Chicago Cubs. This all brings us up to the present.
Bonds is a handful of home runs away from the all time home run record. Sosa has hit a few more dingers after his milestone blast. McGwire has not been heard from in years.
I'm told by talking heads that Bonds is a lock for the Hall of Fame. And after Sosa hit his 600th HR, I was told, surprisngly, that he was also a Hall of Famer. But Mark McGwire, even with 583 home runs, is left off of that list.
The excuse that many use to back up their claim that Bonds is a Hall of Famer, is that A) he will be the all time home run king, and B) he was a Hall of Famer before the steroid era. I will give them that.
But Sosa is the more peculiar pick. Before this season, Sosa was just as crucified as McGwire was. His season in Baltimore, to many, was proof that Sosa must have gone off the juice, as his numbers were way down from his career averages.
Just as soon as 600 left the yard, though, I was told that he was a Hall of Famer, because only four other men had hit the 600 plateau. But my question is, if Sosa is a lock at 600, how is McGwire not a lock just 17 shy of 600?
It is a double standard I am growing very tired of. My thought has always been that McGwire and Sosa either enter the Hall as a pair, or are left out as a pair. They both had their best seasons during the steroid-era. They both looked cartoonish and muscle-bound during their assault on the home run record. And they both suffered a fall from grace that hadn't been seen in baseball since Pete Rose.
I understand why Bonds will be let in. But how is Sosa in, if McGwire is not? In an era where sportswriter blowhards will blab and contradict themselves, I don't know if I will ever find an answer.
1998 feels so long ago.